Originally posted by Karel
Portfolio of the Week
Collapse
This topic is closed.
X
X
-
My appologies....
Originally posted by skiracerLye,
You changed the rules just so that you could avert situations like this with our picks. Down over 13% in 2 days! Regardless of how well and fat you're doing in your personal portfolio it's not indicative an has nothing to do with what we're trying to accompolish here. If you were swing trading this stock in your personal portfolio would you still be holding on in hope of it changing direction? You really should consider exiting any loss over 7% and pick something new to try an recoup some of the loss to try and make the overall % of the POTW portfolio stronger. It's really bringing the rest of the portfolio down an isn't a fair indication of what we can do an how good we are. Spike and BJ, in their test portfolio's, would have exited their positions by now an added to their stronger positions. Still 1 1/2 days left to make some move to try and strengthen the POTW results. Lets treat it like it's our own money. Isn't that what you've been trying to get across to the rest of us?
I took the short position because I thought it would "pay off". You are correct that I have demonstrated poor judgment by holding it this long.... I would not have held it if it were in my actual portfolio, I use much tighter stops on short trades than 7% too (especially in a bull market).... Plain and simple it was a bad pick and played poorly after the fact.... I'll try not to finish in last place this week.
AND.... I'll play picks from my real portfolio in the future. Sorry dude.BEEF!... it's whats for dinner!
Comment
-
-
Europeeeeans are way too emotional!
Originally posted by KarelNo it isn't, but as far as I understand Lye, the POTW doesn't count... which makes things a bit complicated. Lye seems to want to use the POTW as a kind of short list for a 'real' portfolio, real money he says, I would be a bit more careful. So on the one hand we have the players, who would like to win and see the POTW do well (and beat stupid things like the market and my Mechanical Fund), and on the other hand we have Lye, who doesn't care about such trifles and is only interested in making money with our picks. (eh, Lye?)
One of the reasons I brought my Fund into is, is that it should be possible to beat it, and let's see if the POTW can do it. Perhaps Lye will also disclose his other plans, to the point where we can see how well he does off us.
Regards,
Karel
Now as for Captmatrix, the homeless dude hangin out at BillyJoes?.... He's made me FREAKIN $$$ Millions $$$!..... AND I COULDN"T HAVE DONE IT WITHOUT $$$MR.MARKET$$$'s Forum!.... Thank YOU $$$Mr. Market$$$!!!!
BTW Karel.... IF this FREAKIN POTW did NOT "count" to me? I would NOT put up the FREAKIN effort necessary to grow it.... that I FREAKIN HAVE!!!! I would not have BEGGED you To PLAY and I would not have answered youR Sh*t-a$$ post.... Now I'm shorting GES just for the hell-of-it... (in my REAL LIFE portfolio)!BEEF!... it's whats for dinner!
Comment
-
-
Lye,
We all take picks that for whatever reasons go off in the wrong direction. There's nothing wrong with that an it happens. It's how we manage the good ones and bad ones that separate the wheat from the chaff. I'm not being critical of the pick only the management of the position after a specific point. You want all of us to give the best we can to increase our chances of a higher % of gains. It's only fair that the same expectations apply to everyone one of us. Where any one of us finishes is insignificant as long as we can say in the end that we applied our best to the endeavor for the whole. Good show an you're right about it not being over until the fat lady sings so the last day and a half can make a difference.THE SKIRACER'S EDGE: MAKE THE EDGE IN YOUR FAVOR
Comment
-
-
@Lye: Well, that's clear, sort of, more or less. And GES might be a good short at this point, with 9% added the last two days. I wouldn't say: better than CNVR, however.
Regards,
KarelMy Investopedia portfolio
(You need to have a (free) Investopedia or Facebook login, sorry!)
Comment
-
-
Originally posted by Karel@Lye: Well, that's clear, sort of, more or less. And GES might be a good short at this point, with 9% added the last two days. I wouldn't say: better than CNVR, however.
Regards,
KarelBEEF!... it's whats for dinner!
Comment
-
-
Originally posted by LyehopperI kinda like hearing you two speak for me.... Remember fellas: It ain't over till the freakin fat lady sings!
http://img456.imageshack.us/img456/3444/fatlady5nn.png
It took a long time to download that picture and after the wait it ruined my lunch . And Lye ,I don't care what you do with my picks. I'm just happy you're running the POTW.
billyjoe
Comment
-
-
Originally posted by billyjoeIt took a long time to download that picture and after the wait it ruined my lunch . And Lye ,I don't care what you do with my picks. I'm just happy you're running the POTW.
billyjoe
OK Fellas!.... I'm Covering my "now famous" CNVR short and I'm shorting one from My real life Lyehopper Hollow Portfolio!!!! SHORT SELL NRPH.... Now!BEEF!... it's whats for dinner!
Comment
-
-
Originally posted by billyjoeSpike,
My broker says we're talking a "sell limit" order here and not a "premarket stop" order or is this all just semantics and it's the same thing?
billyjoe
But strictly speaking the term 'premarket stop' is misleading so disregard it.
And just on stops, for those who don't know the difference, market orders will slip and chase the bid until you're completely flat, so you'll get as much slippage as the market forces demand, whereas limit orders will only slip as much as you specify, and thus not guaranteeing that you fully exit (or even commence to exit) your position, as the bid could drop below your limit, and the ask chases the bid so your limit order is left stranded and unfilled.
Comment
-
-
Originally posted by LyehopperSo are you selling GES, nailing down your profit and replacing it with another stellar pick Karel? [...]
Regards,
KarelMy Investopedia portfolio
(You need to have a (free) Investopedia or Facebook login, sorry!)
Comment
-
-
stop limit may help you
Originally posted by billyjoeSpike,
My broker says we're talking a "sell limit" order here and not a "premarket stop" order or is this all just semantics and it's the same thing?
billyjoe
whipsawed. Here is a link to SEC.gov defining STOPS.
http://www.sec.gov/answers/stopord.htm
TimTim - Retired Problem Solver
Comment
-
Comment